Hello, I’m KENTA, Blackbeard, Marshall D. Teach, is one of the greatest rivals of the protagonist, Luffy, in One Piece. His abilities and true identity are surrounded by many mysteries, and numerous fan theories have been proposed. In this post, I’ll highlight some of the most noteworthy theories. Let’s dive into the mystery of Blackbeard together!
1. The Giant Octopus Theory: Is Blackbeard a “Giant Octopus”?
The first theory we’ll look at is the unique idea that Blackbeard could be a “giant octopus.” Octopuses have three hearts, eight arms, and, in some species, can stay awake for long periods. Based on these characteristics, there is a theory that Blackbeard might be a “giant octopus” or a “half-octopus.”
1.1 Reasoning from the Octopus’s Characteristics
The three hearts and eight arms of an octopus are said to resemble Blackbeard’s features. In the story, Buggy mentions that Blackbeard never sleeps, and the three skulls on Blackbeard’s Jolly Roger could symbolize the three hearts. Some fans also suggest that Blackbeard’s ability to hold multiple Devil Fruits might be linked to the number of hearts an octopus has.
1.2 Contradictions of the Octopus Theory
However, there are significant flaws in this theory. If Blackbeard were truly a “giant octopus,” his physical features should be more apparent, but such depictions do not appear in the story. Additionally, Blackbeard spent many years in the Whitebeard Pirates, and if he had such octopus-like features, his crew would likely have noticed. These points lead to the conclusion that the octopus theory is not very plausible.
2. The Cerberus Theory: Is Blackbeard the Three-Headed Dog?
Next, we have the theory that Blackbeard is the user of the Cerberus Devil Fruit. Cerberus, the three-headed dog from Greek mythology, guards the underworld. This theory has gained popularity as a way to explain why Blackbeard possesses three distinct personalities or abilities.
2.1 Cerberus’s Characteristics and Their Connection to Blackbeard
Some believe that the three skulls on Blackbeard’s Jolly Roger represent the three heads of Cerberus, and others think that the three claw marks on Shanks’s left eye might be a nod to Cerberus. There is also speculation that Blackbeard may have had the Cerberus abilities before obtaining the Yami Yami no Mi (Dark-Dark Fruit).
2.2 Contradictions of the Cerberus Theory
However, this theory also has its flaws. If Blackbeard had the powers of Cerberus, it would mean he had already consumed two Devil Fruits, which is impossible according to the story’s rules. As such, the timeline for this theory doesn’t hold up, making the Cerberus theory unlikely.
3. The Rocks D. Xebec Theory: Is Blackbeard a Descendant of Rocks?
Another theory suggests that Blackbeard is a descendant of the legendary pirate Rocks D. Xebec. Rocks was feared as one of the strongest pirates, and some fans believe that Blackbeard’s actions and goals may be connected to Rocks’s legacy.
3.1 The Connection to Rocks
One point raised in this theory is that the name of Blackbeard’s ship, the Saul, contains the name “Xebec,” linking Blackbeard to Rocks. Furthermore, Blackbeard’s goal of becoming the “King of the World” aligns with Rocks’s ambitions, which strengthens the idea that Blackbeard might be related to him.
3.2 Contradictions of the Rocks Theory
However, information about Rocks is still shrouded in mystery, and there is no conclusive proof that Blackbeard is a direct descendant. Additionally, even if Blackbeard were related to Rocks, it’s difficult to explain his unique abilities based solely on that connection. As a result, this theory is also not completely convincing.
4. The Yami Yami no Mi Theory: Is Blackbeard’s Body a Result of Devil Fruit Powers?
Finally, we explore the theory that Blackbeard’s unusual body is a result of the powers of the Yami Yami no Mi. The Yami Yami no Mi is a Logia-type Devil Fruit that grants the ability to control darkness and attract objects. It’s theorized that this power enabled Blackbeard to absorb other Devil Fruits into his body.
4.1 The Effect of the Yami Yami no Mi on Blackbeard’s Physiology
By consuming the Yami Yami no Mi, Blackbeard not only gained the ability to control gravity but also underwent a physical transformation that allowed him to host multiple Devil Fruits. If this theory is true, it could explain Blackbeard’s abnormal physiology.
4.2 Contradictions of the Yami Yami no Mi Theory
However, this theory is still lacking key details. How the Yami Yami no Mi grants the ability to hold multiple Devil Fruits is not yet explained in the story. To fully accept this theory, more information would be required.
Conclusion
Blackbeard’s powers remain one of the biggest mysteries in One Piece, but each of the theories presented offers compelling evidence for his unique abilities. In particular, the Cerberus theory and the Yami Yami no Mi body transformation theory suggest that Blackbeard may not possess just one power but a combination of forces, making them especially intriguing.
The key takeaway from my analysis is that Blackbeard’s powers will likely play a major role in the final chapters of One Piece. We’ll have to wait for future developments to learn more about his true nature, but one thing is for sure: the day Blackbeard’s true identity is revealed is sure to be an unforgettable moment in the story.
At MangaZamurai, we continue to share deep dives and analyses about Japanese manga with fans around the world. Be sure to check out our other articles as well!
